Opinion
H&P encourages historians to comment the issues of the day, either with rapid responses or full opinion pieces. The H&P office can help historians to publish opinion pieces in the national media or on this website.
- Rapid responses
- H&P opinion pieces
- Historians' opinion in the media
- 'Lest we forget' series, in association with Open Democracy
- Advice for historians
Rapid responses
Historians provide rapid comment on the issues of the day:
- History offers no route-map: these spending cuts have no precedent
Glen O'Hara (22 June 2010) - MMR, autism and the history of medical controversies
Matthew Smith (25 May 2010) - Dr Liam Fox: More Palmerston than Blair?
Adam Shelley (24 May 2010) - Nick Clegg and the not-so-great 1832 Reform Act
Sarah Richardson (20 May 2010) - BA cabin crew: the London dockers of our time?
Jim Phillips (17 May 2010) - A Conservative - Labour coalition?
David Edgerton (11 May 2010) - Another election this year? Historical perspectives on the hung parliament
Richard Toye (7 May 2010) - Where will the axe fall? Public opinion and spending cuts
Henry Irving (30 April 2010) - History suggests that Scandinavian policies will be lost in translation
Glen O'Hara (21 April 2010) - A return to Victorian levels of railway building?
Colin Divall (12 April 2010) - Historians comment on the 2010 Budget announcement and debate
(25 March 2010) - Historians respond to the Queen's speech
(18 November 2009) - Why MPs are paid
Greg Rosen (18 May 2009) - The true lessons of Thatcher's rise
Richard Toye (5 May 2009) - H&P historians' respond to the budget
(22 April 2009)
H&P opinion pieces
Historians write exclusively for the H&P website:
- What's a 'back office' for? The case of policing
Chris A. Williams (22 June 2010) - Scrapping the police 'stop' form
James Whitfield (24 May 2010) - The 'Great' Reform Act of 1832: Clegg's unfortunate parallel
Steven Fielding (20 May 2010) - If Cameron is the new Baldwin, where does this leave Clegg?
Steven Fielding (19 May 2010) - Avoiding Irish entanglements
Iain McLean (12 May 2010) - That Cabinet Manual in full
Iain McLean (7 May 2010) - Proportional Representation: historical destiny beckons?
Simon Szreter (6 May 2010) - Nuclear elections
Matthew Grant (4 May 2010) - When the wheels came off Brown's campaign bus
Jon Lawrence (29 April 2010) - Cabinet Office quest for written constitution should worry historians
Andrew Blick (23 April 2010) - Revisiting the 'Big Society'
Henry Irving (23 April 2010) - Don't mention the war? History suggests foreign policy can swing voters
Jenna Phillips (22 April 2010) - History suggests "boom and bust" won't go away
David Hall-Matthews (12 April 2010) - Choosing your history: Wave energy development in the UK
Campbell Wilson (22 March 2010) - Cameron and the renewal of the 'property-owning democracy'
Matthew Francis (26 February 2010) - Recreating our political history
Steven Fielding (8 February 2010) - Political posters in history
Christopher Burgess (12 January 2010) - Slavery and climate change: lessons to be learned
Jean-Francois Mouhot (16 December 2009) - 'Hijacking' history
Ivan Pregnolato (2 December 2009) - More sex, lies and trafficking
Jane Berney (2 December 2009) - 1989: Divided memories, East and West
James Mark (10 November 2009) - Pinstriped fascism
Matthew Feldman (4 November 2009) - The case for historical advisers in government
Yoav J. Tenembaum (29 October 2009) - Broadband terrorism: A new face of fascism
Matthew Feldman (22 September 2009) - Are school standards slipping?
Adrian Elliott (18 August 2009) - Open public primaries
Jon Lawrence (12 August 2009) - Talking to the Taliban: Lessons from Northern Ireland
John Bew (29 June 2009) - Death of a Speaker
Ann Lyon (19 June 2009) - Car scrapping scheme could learn from green victories of the past
Erin Gill (19 May 2009) - UK Manufacturing decline is the real story of the Budget
Scott Newton (5 May 2009) - History could have predicted a global financial crisis
David Hall-Matthews (28 April 2009) - Cameron's history lesson
Richard Toye (28 April 2009) - The Energy Bill - tinkering while the planet burns?
Campbell Wilson and Dave Elliott (21 July 2008) - Can compulsion work? What history has to say about raising the school leaving age.
Nicola Sheldon (26 June 2008) - The 'ziz-zagging' of British Prime Ministers
Andrew Blick and George Jones (3 April 2008)
Opinion pieces in the media
Articles by members of the H&P Network published in the national media:
- The reduction in maternal death rates is not a Lib-Con achievement
Graham Mooney (Guardian, 27 June 2010) - Austerity was a hard sell in the 40s. Today it's harder still
David Kynaston (Guardian, 22 June 2010) - What are academic historians for?
Martin Johnes (WalesHome.org, 27 May 2010) - Brown begins his adventures in the afterlife
Kevin Theakston (Yorkshire Post, 18 May 2010) - Liberal revival? A cruel illusion if the past is anything to go by
Richard Toye (Western Morning News, 13 May 2010) - Tory-Liberal parallels with the Fox-North coalition
Paul Lay (History Today, 13 May 2010) - Electoral reform: The battle for fairer votes begins here
Iain McLean (Independent, 10 May 2010) - Advice for a new government
David Reynolds (Guardian, 8 May 2010) - ConDemnation?
Steven Fielding (University of Nottingham Election 2010 blog, 10 May 2010) - Scrap the Tory plans and bring in PR
Iain McLean (Guardian, 2 May 2010) - Hung!
Steven Fielding (University of Nottingham Election 2010 blog, 2 May 2010) - Broken Britain and Big Society: Back to the 1930s?
John Welshman (OUP blog, 29 April 2010) - Changing the rules by stealth: the UK's constitution is being written as the public follows the election
Andrew Blick (OurKingdom, 29 April, 2010) - Should Labour love coalitions?
Greg Rosen (Progress online, 21 April, 2010) - Britain's third party looks to history
Peter Clarke (Financial Times, 20 April 2010) - Meet the Nick Clegg of 1942
Steven Fielding (Guardian, 18 April 2010) - Thinking in time: does health policy need history?
Virginia Berridge (Lancet, March 2010) - Second thoughts: supporting teenage mothers
Ofra Koffman (Society Guardian, 7 October 2009) - History without bunk
Alastair Reid (Guardian Unlimited, 20 September 2009) - The age old problem of pupils skipping school
Nicola Sheldon (Guardian, 26 February 2009) - How to talk about redistribution: Ben Jackson offers a historical perspective
Ben Jackson (Compass, 30 September 2008) - Polyclinics in London: historical issues
Virginia Berridge (London Journal of Primary Care, simultaneously published as Polyclinics: haven't we been there before? by the British Medical Journal, 23 May 2008) - Avoiding past mistakes
Jim Moher (Guardian Unlimited, 9 September 2007) - Past opportunities
Virginia Berridge (Society Guardian, 20 June 2007) - Enlist the Blitz spirit, get out the carbon ration book [pdf file, 32KB]
Mark Roodhouse (Financial Times, 14 March 2007) - Blair Must not repeat Attlee's pensions mistake [pdf file, 25KB]
Pat Thane (Financial Times, 24 May 2006)
'Lest we forget' series, in association with Open Democracy
The Lest we forget series is produced in association with openDemocracy.
- The forgotten impact of a war that didn't happen
Holger Nehring, 30 March 2010
Holger Nehring suggests that the impact of the Cold War arms race on politics and society has been forgotten. - Forgotten lessons: Palestine and the British empire
James Renton, 19 March 2010
James Renton examines the legacy of British involvement in Palestine, arguing that mandate-era misjudgements are being readily repeated. - Iraq and the fig leaf of just war theory
Bob Brecher, 9 February 2010
Bob Brecher examines how dissention over the legality of the Iraq war, and the history of Western military interventions since 1945, reveal the paucity of international law's moral underpinnings. - The politics of poppy day
Lucy Noakes, 26 January 2010
As Wootton Basset pays its respects to soldiers killed in the Afghanistan conflict, Lucy Noakes explores the fraught history of war remembrance.
For information on submissions to the Lest we forget series, please refer to the guidelines on the openSecurity website or contact daniel.macarthur-seal@opendemocracy.net.
Advice for historians on writing opinion pieces
To be accepted for publication on this website, contributors should observe the following guidelines:
- Articles should be 700-900 words of text in short, clear paragraphs
- Use a punchy, accessible style with no wasted words
- Get to the point in the first sentence and hook your argument firmly into the current issue
- This is an opportunity to give your opinions, but not to rant
- Focus on the current issue, with history used sparingly to make your case
- Deploy brief historical examples and quotations where appropriate
- Read recent press coverage of the issue at hand and make sure your angle is original
- The last paragraph should reinforce your point and the relevance of history
The History News Service website provides excellent advice for historians on writing opinion pieces, with samples and style guidelines. If you have an idea for an article and would like to discuss it, or to submit a draft, please contact Ruth Evans (ruth.evans@sas.ac.uk). We can also help you to place articles with newspapers.
Copyright
Users of the website are welcome to download and reproduce its contents consistent with the fair dealing exceptions, in particular fair dealing for the purpose of research or private study. In submitting their papers to this website authors are considered to have granted the editors a licence to reproduce their work in electronic form, but they continue to retain copyright in their work. The editors retain copyright in the website as a compilation or database, as well as in the underlying source code as a computer program.
Disclaimer
The views expressed on this website are those of the authors and are not necessarily those of the editors or other staff members of the Centre for Contemporary British History, University of London, the Centre for History in Public Health, University of London or the Faculty of History, University of Cambridge.